little girl holding a pumpkin on her head. Experts say pumpkin picking is best the first two weeks o...
Catherine Falls Commercial/Getty

Here's Why Patience Is Key When Picking Out A Pumpkin, According To Experts

Originally Published: 

Gather ‘round everyone because I have an important announcement to make: Before you know it, the pumpkins will be here! Whether you frolic through a patch or fill your grocery cart, having a fresh pumpkin in your home just makes it feel like fall. But knowing the perfect time to get your pumpkin is the key to creating masterpiece jack-o-lanterns that won’t end up looking like rotting flesh on your front porch in a week’s time.

How Long Can You Expect Your Pumpkin To Last?

In speaking with pumpkin experts (yes, there are experts), it seems pumpkins can actually last for quite some time, provided you take care of them properly. "Pumpkins will last eight weeks in a controlled environment (not exposed to direct sunlight or rain),” Jade Egger from The Pumpkin Patch, a third generation family farm that practices sustainable agriculture on Sauvie Island, Oregon, tells Romper in an email. (If you time it right, you can double your Halloween pumpkins as Thanksgiving harvest decorations.)

When Should You Buy Your Pumpkin?

Come early September, you can definitely find me in line for a steamy pumpkin spice beverage, but when it comes to purchasing actual pumpkins, I tend to wait a bit further into spooky season. From carving to tablescaping, decorating with pumpkins is peak fall, but timing is everything. Experts agree that even if that pumpkin fever hits you earlier than it usually does myself and you just can't wait until October to buy yours, you should be OK.

Pumpkins aren't just the quintessential symbol of fall, they're also a big business. An estimated 152 million Americans, or about 46% of the population, are expected to purchase a pumpkin during the 2020 fall season, according to a report from Finder.com. At an average cost of $4.18 per pumpkin, that’s a major chunk of change to be made. But all that money will be for naught if you don't consider when you do your purchasing (and carving).

akaplummer/E+/Getty Images

Though your kiddos might start screaming at you to stop everything and load up on gourds the second they see all those pumpkin patches pop up around town, patience is a virtue you may want to instill in them when it comes to picking the right one. Unless, of course, you enjoy racing around town the night before Halloween scouring for another one because yours has turned into a science experiment on your front porch.

If you wait too long, however, supply may be the bigger issue. "By the third weekend in October, our patch is pretty picked over. We suggest the first two weeks in October for picking," Egger tells Romper. Another pro-tip from Egger is to try and shop during the week to avoid the weekend crowds and long lines for the hay rides, which you know your kids are going to beg you to do.

When Should You Carve Your Pumpkin?

Carving is an entirely different matter when it comes to timing though. "Carved pumpkins break down extremely fast,” Egger explains. “We would suggest carving your pumpkin three to five days prior to Halloween." Did you hear that? Do not rush the carving!

But what if you don't want to carve your pumpkin? If baking, displaying, or decorating your pumpkins is more your speed, Suzannah Underwood at Moorpark, California's popular Underwood Family Farms has a few tips for which pumpkins to pick for these particular activities. "Sugar baby pumpkins are best for baking,” Underwood tells Romper. “They can also be painted on, but the skins are very thick, so they make it difficult to carve."

Underwood also encourages people to "step outside of your comfort zone and try different kinds of pumpkins other than the traditional jack-o’-lantern. Cinderellas, Aladdins, Ghost — white — pumpkins and even squash can make for great decorations."

Whether you are looking for that one perfect pumpkin, or a plethora of them to fulfill all your fall dreams, with a little care and the right timing you'll be a pumpkin picking pro quicker than you can say "trick-or-treat."


Jade Egger, The Pumpkin Patch

Suzannah Underwood, Underwood Family Farms

This article was originally published on